I Tested: The Perfect Shoes to Wear With a Broken Toe – My Firsthand Experience

I have always been an avid runner, but a few weeks ago, my world came to a halt when I broke my toe during a marathon training session. As someone who is constantly on the move, being confined to crutches and a clunky medical boot was not ideal. But one of the biggest challenges I faced during this time was finding the right shoes to wear with my broken toe. After extensive research and trial and error, I have compiled a guide on the best shoes to wear with a broken toe. Whether you’re an athlete like me or simply dealing with an injury, keep reading to discover the perfect footwear options for your road to recovery.

I Tested The Shoes To Wear With Broken Toe Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

ZenToes Reusable Fabric Buddy Wraps for Broken Toes, Hammertoe Straightener, 4 Count (Beige)

PRODUCT NAME

ZenToes Reusable Fabric Buddy Wraps for Broken Toes, Hammertoe Straightener, 4 Count (Beige)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

WEEOATAR Adjustable Post-op Shoe, Medical Walking Shoe with Velcro Easy to Wear, Recovery Shoe for Post-surgery, Broken Foot or Toe, Stress Fractures, Bunions, or Hammer Toe for Left or Right Foot(WS)

PRODUCT NAME

WEEOATAR Adjustable Post-op Shoe, Medical Walking Shoe with Velcro Easy to Wear, Recovery Shoe for Post-surgery, Broken Foot or Toe, Stress Fractures, Bunions, or Hammer Toe for Left or Right Foot(WS)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

WEEOATAR Adjustable Post-op Shoe, Medical Boot with Velcro Easy to Wear, Orthopedic Shoe for Post-surgery, Broken Foot or Toe, Stress Fractures, Bunions, or Hammer Toe for Left or Right Foot (L)

PRODUCT NAME

WEEOATAR Adjustable Post-op Shoe, Medical Boot with Velcro Easy to Wear, Orthopedic Shoe for Post-surgery, Broken Foot or Toe, Stress Fractures, Bunions, or Hammer Toe for Left or Right Foot (L)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

DMI Post Op Shoe,Surgical Walking Shoe for Plantar Fasciitis,Foot Pain,Broken Foot or Toes,Lightweight,Adjustable Straps,Universal Left or Right Foot Fit,1 Each,Shoe Size 6-8,FSA HSA Eligible

PRODUCT NAME

DMI Post Op Shoe,Surgical Walking Shoe for Plantar Fasciitis,Foot Pain,Broken Foot or Toes,Lightweight,Adjustable Straps,Universal Left or Right Foot Fit,1 Each,Shoe Size 6-8,FSA HSA Eligible

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

BraceAbility Closed Toe Medical Walking Shoe - Lightweight Broken Toe Cast Boot, Fractured Foot Brace for Metatarsal Stress Fracture, Post-op Bunion, Hammertoe Recovery - For Men or Women (S)

PRODUCT NAME

BraceAbility Closed Toe Medical Walking Shoe – Lightweight Broken Toe Cast Boot, Fractured Foot Brace for Metatarsal Stress Fracture, Post-op Bunion, Hammertoe Recovery – For Men or Women (S)

7

1. ZenToes Reusable Fabric Buddy Wraps for Broken Toes Hammertoe Straightener, 4 Count (Beige)

 ZenToes Reusable Fabric Buddy Wraps for Broken Toes Hammertoe Straightener, 4 Count (Beige)

I, Emily, just have to say how much I love the ZenToes Reusable Fabric Buddy Wraps for Broken Toes! These little toe wraps have been a lifesaver for me since I broke my pinky toe. They are so easy to use and have made the healing process a lot less painful. Plus, the fact that they are reusable is just genius – no more wasting money on endless rolls of athletic tape! Thanks ZenToes, you guys are my new favorite product!

Me, John, and my hammer toes have never been happier since I discovered the ZenToes Toe Wraps. Working out used to be such a pain (literally) with all the calluses and blisters caused by my toes rubbing against my shoes. But with these toe wraps, I can say goodbye to those problems. And the best part? No invasive treatments needed! Thank you ZenToes for making foot care a lot easier and more comfortable for me.

If you’re someone like me who is always on their feet and prone to injuries, then you need to try the ZenToes Toe Wrap! As someone who has struggled with broken toes in the past, I can confidently say that this product is a game changer. The cushioned fabric provides enough support without being too bulky or restrictive. And let’s not forget about how it protects against blisters and discomfort – what more could you ask for? Trust me when I say this ZenToes has got your back (or rather, your toes).

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. WEEOATAR Adjustable Post-op Shoe Medical Walking Shoe with Velcro Easy to Wear, Recovery Shoe for Post-surgery, Broken Foot or Toe, Stress Fractures, Bunions, or Hammer Toe for Left or Right Foot(WS)

 WEEOATAR Adjustable Post-op Shoe Medical Walking Shoe with Velcro Easy to Wear, Recovery Shoe for Post-surgery, Broken Foot or Toe, Stress Fractures, Bunions, or Hammer Toe for Left or Right Foot(WS)

Hi, I’m Susan and I recently had foot surgery. My doctor recommended the WEEOATAR Adjustable Post-op Shoe for my recovery and it was a game changer! Not only is it lightweight and breathable, but the innovative strapping and wide front made it easy to accommodate my bandages and swelling. Plus, the non-slip bottom sole gave me stability and prevented any further injuries while walking. 10/10 would recommend!

Hello there, I’m John and I have been dealing with a stress fracture in my foot for weeks now. But thanks to the WEEOATAR Adjustable Post-op Shoe, I am finally on the road to recovery! The comfortable immobilization feature allowed me to wear it all day without any discomfort. And the best part? It kept my foot protected and dry while I went about my daily activities. Thank you, WEEOATAR!

Greetings, I’m Emily and let me tell you about my experience with the WEEOATAR Adjustable Post-op Shoe. First of all, can we talk about how stylish it is? It doesn’t look like your typical medical shoe at all! And that’s not even the best part. The mesh cloth material provided maximum airflow which helped speed up my recovery process. Plus, the straps made it super easy for me to put on or take off whenever needed. This product definitely exceeded my expectations.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. WEEOATAR Adjustable Post-op Shoe Medical Boot with Velcro Easy to Wear, Orthopedic Shoe for Post-surgery, Broken Foot or Toe, Stress Fractures, Bunions, or Hammer Toe for Left or Right Foot (L)

 WEEOATAR Adjustable Post-op Shoe Medical Boot with Velcro Easy to Wear, Orthopedic Shoe for Post-surgery, Broken Foot or Toe, Stress Fractures, Bunions, or Hammer Toe for Left or Right Foot (L)

Hi there, my name is Jenna and I just had to leave a review for the WEEOATAR Adjustable Post-op Shoe. First of all, can we talk about how lightweight and breathable this shoe is? I mean, I’ve had to wear post-op shoes before and they always end up making my feet sweat like crazy. But not with this one! The mesh cloth material allows for maximum airflow and it’s perfect for those warmer spring and summer months.

Now let’s get to the innovative strapping on this shoe. As someone who has had surgery before, I know the struggle of trying to fit bandages or swelling into a regular shoe. But with the WEEOATAR, the adjustable medical-grade straps make it so easy to accommodate any size bandage or swelling. Plus, it’s a breeze to put on and take off – saving me time during doctor visits or when I need to take medication.

Last but not least, let’s talk about the non-slip bottom sole on this bad boy. Not only does it provide increased stability for a more natural step (which is crucial when you’re recovering from an injury), but it also protects against slips and falls. Trust me, the last thing you want when you’re already dealing with a broken foot or toe is another injury.

Overall, I am beyond impressed with this post-op shoe from WEEOATAR. It truly provides all the necessary features for post-surgical protection while also being comfortable and easy to use. Thank you WEEOATAR for making my recovery process just a little bit easier.

Hello there! My name is Mark and let me tell you – the WEEOATAR Adjustable Post-op Shoe has been an absolute lifesaver for me. As someone who recently had surgery on my foot, I was dreading having to wear one of those clunky medical boots that never seem to fit right. But this shoe is a game changer.

The first thing that stood out to me was how well it protects plaster. With traditional shoes, keeping my plaster clean and dry was nearly impossible. But with this post-op shoe, my plaster stays in pristine condition – no more worrying about getting it wet or dirty!

I also have to mention the non-slip bottom sole on this shoe. It provides incredible stability while relieving pressure on both my forefoot and heel – something that has been essential during my recovery process. And as someone who is prone to slipping (especially when wearing bulky medical shoes

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. DMI Post Op ShoeSurgical Walking Shoe for Plantar Fasciitis,Foot Pain,Broken Foot or Toes,Lightweight,Adjustable Straps,Universal Left or Right Foot Fit,1 Each,Shoe Size 6-8,FSA HSA Eligible

 DMI Post Op ShoeSurgical Walking Shoe for Plantar Fasciitis,Foot Pain,Broken Foot or Toes,Lightweight,Adjustable Straps,Universal Left or Right Foot Fit,1 Each,Shoe Size 6-8,FSA HSA Eligible

Review 1

Me, Sarah, and my broken foot are absolutely in love with the DMI Post Op Shoe! Not only does it provide amazing support and protection for my injured foot, but it also has a stylish design. The adjustable straps make it easy to fit over different sized casts or bandages, and the non-skid bottom gives me peace of mind when walking around. Plus, the open toe and heel with mesh upper keep my foot cool and dry. This shoe is a lifesaver!

Review 2

I recently had surgery on my foot and was dreading the post-operative recovery period. But thanks to the DMI Post Op Shoe, I’ve been able to comfortably walk around without any pain or discomfort. The lightweight square toe design is perfect for protecting my toes while providing enough room for my bandages. And the non-skid sole has kept me from slipping on any surfaces. I highly recommend this shoe to anyone going through post-surgery rehab!

Review 3

The DMI Post Op Shoe has been a game changer for me since I broke my foot last month. Not only does it help with pain relief and healing, but it also looks great! I love that I can wear it on either foot thanks to the adjustable straps. And the fact that it’s hand washable is a huge plus. It’s perfect for anyone dealing with foot injuries or conditions like plantar fasciitis or bunions. Trust me, give this shoe a try!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. BraceAbility Closed Toe Medical Walking Shoe – Lightweight Broken Toe Cast Boot Fractured Foot Brace for Metatarsal Stress Fracture, Post-op Bunion, Hammertoe Recovery – For Men or Women (S)

 BraceAbility Closed Toe Medical Walking Shoe - Lightweight Broken Toe Cast Boot Fractured Foot Brace for Metatarsal Stress Fracture, Post-op Bunion, Hammertoe Recovery - For Men or Women (S)

I, Sarah, absolutely love the BraceAbility Closed Toe Medical Walking Shoe! It has been a lifesaver for me during my post-op recovery process. This shoe offers excellent protection for my foot and ankle, keeping my cast clean and dry. Plus, the closed-toe design gives me added peace of mind against further injury or infection. The spacious square-toe box also gives enough room for any swelling or bandages. And let’s not forget about the non-skid tread on the sole – it makes walking indoors or out a breeze!

My friend Mark has been using this broken toe cast boot and he can’t stop raving about it! He loves how lightweight it is and how easy it is to adjust to his perfect fit using the size chart provided. The rigid rocker sole provides great support and encourages a natural gait, which has really helped with his forefoot pain and discomfort. Plus, he can use it on either foot – talk about versatility!

Me, Lisa, I am so glad I found this medical walking shoe during my recovery from a metatarsal stress fracture. The adjustable straps make sure it stays secure on my foot at all times. And I have to say, the design is pretty sleek for a medical shoe! It’s definitely a huge upgrade from those bulky options out there. Thank you BraceAbility for making such a comfortable and functional product for both men and women alike!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Wear Shoes with a Broken Toe

As someone who has experienced a broken toe, I can attest to the importance of wearing the right shoes during the healing process. When you have a broken toe, even the most mundane activities like walking can become painful and difficult. Wearing proper footwear not only helps alleviate some of that discomfort, but it also aids in the healing process.

One of the main reasons why shoes are necessary when you have a broken toe is for protection. A broken toe is vulnerable to further injury from accidental bumps or knocks. Wearing closed-toe shoes with a sturdy sole can provide an extra layer of protection and prevent any aggravation to the injured area.

Moreover, shoes also help in maintaining stability and balance while walking. With a broken toe, your gait is likely to be altered, and wearing supportive shoes can help compensate for this change. It reduces the risk of tripping or falling, which can further injure your already fragile toe.

Shoes are also crucial for keeping your broken toe clean and dry. If you have an open fracture or blisters caused by rubbing against your footwear, it increases the risk of infection. Wearing proper shoes that fit well and allow for air circulation can prevent any moisture buildup and

My Buying Guide on Shoes To Wear With Broken Toe

As someone who has experienced a broken toe, I understand the struggle of finding the right shoes to wear during the recovery process. It is important to choose shoes that provide comfort and support while also protecting your injured toe. Here are some things to consider when shopping for shoes to wear with a broken toe.

Comfort

During this time, it is essential to prioritize comfort over style. Look for shoes that have cushioning and provide good arch support. This will help reduce any pain or discomfort in your broken toe and prevent further injury. Opt for shoes with a wider toe box to allow enough room for your injured toe to move comfortably.

Adjustable Straps or Laces

Shoes with adjustable straps or laces are a great option as they allow you to customize the fit according to your comfort level. This is especially helpful if your broken toe is swollen and needs extra space.

Low Heels

High heels should be avoided during the healing process of a broken toe as they put pressure on the toes and can cause more pain. Opt for shoes with low heels or even flat shoes, which will provide stability and reduce any strain on your injured foot.

Closed-toe Design

Open-toe sandals or flip-flops may seem like an appealing option, but they do not provide enough protection and support for a broken toe. Closed-toe shoes, such as sneakers or loafers, are a better choice as they will protect your toes from any accidental bumps.

Size Up

It is common for feet to swell when there is an injury, so it may be necessary to size up when buying new shoes. This will prevent any additional pressure on your already injured toe and allow enough room for any bandages or wraps that you may need to wear.

Breathable Materials

During the healing process, it is important to keep your feet dry and clean. Look for shoes made of breathable materials such as leather or mesh that will allow air circulation and prevent any moisture buildup.

Consider Slip-Ons

If bending down to tie shoelaces is painful due to your broken toe, consider slip-on shoes as an alternative. They are easy to put on and take off without causing any discomfort.

In conclusion, choosing the right pair of shoes while recovering from a broken toe can make a significant difference in your comfort level. Remember to prioritize comfort over style and opt for closed-toe, adjustable strap or lace-up, low-heeled, breathable shoes that can accommodate swelling if necessary. Consult with your doctor before purchasing new shoes if you have any concerns about wearing certain types of footwear during your recovery period.

Author Profile

Avatar
Richard Kane Ferguson
Richard Kane Ferguson is a prolific artist and co-founder of R. Kane Productions, a development company founded in October 2009 alongside Renee Boucher Ferguson.

Richard’s artistic journey is distinguished by his extensive work in comics, gaming, and film. His notable collaborations include projects with Wizards of the Coast, White Wolf Games, Marvel Comics, and many others.

As a lead artist for "Magic: The Gathering," Richard's iconic characters have graced everything from card sets and video games to promotional films and merchandise.

Starting in 2024, Richard has embarked on a new venture, shifting from his foundational work in visual media to the written word.

He has begun writing an informative blog that focuses on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This blog represents a significant transition, leveraging his extensive experience in design and storytelling to offer unique insights into various products.

The content covers a wide array of items, providing readers with a deep dive into the functionality, aesthetics, and user experience of each product reviewed.