I Tested the Best Ponytail Holders for Thick Hair and Here’s What Happened!

I’ve always struggled with finding the perfect ponytail holder that can actually hold my thick and unruly hair in place. Countless times, I’ve had to deal with hair ties snapping or slipping out of place, ruining my carefully styled ponytail. But after years of searching and trying different options, I’ve finally found the holy grail – ponytail holders specifically designed for thick hair. In this article, I’ll be sharing my top picks for the best ponytail holders for thick hair that will keep your locks in place all day long. Say goodbye to frustrating hair mishaps and hello to effortless and secure ponytails with these must-have accessories.

I Tested The Ponytail Holders For Thick Hair Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

GOODY Ouchless XL & Extra Thick Elastics, Black, 10.0 Count,

PRODUCT NAME

GOODY Ouchless XL & Extra Thick Elastics, Black, 10.0 Count,

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Goody Thick Hair Ties - Athletic Hair Bands 8 Count, Black- Suitable for All Hair Types - Ouchless Hair Accessories for Women and Girls

PRODUCT NAME

Goody Thick Hair Ties – Athletic Hair Bands 8 Count, Black- Suitable for All Hair Types – Ouchless Hair Accessories for Women and Girls

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

100 Pcs Thick Seamless Hair Ties, Ponytail Holders Hair Accessories No Damage for Thick Hair (Natural Colors)

PRODUCT NAME

100 Pcs Thick Seamless Hair Ties, Ponytail Holders Hair Accessories No Damage for Thick Hair (Natural Colors)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Revlon Extra Thick Black Hair Elastics, 15 Count

PRODUCT NAME

Revlon Extra Thick Black Hair Elastics, 15 Count

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

100PCS Large Cotton Seamless Ponytail Holders - Hair Elastics for Thick, Heavy and Curly Hair (2 Inch Diameter) by BAOLI

PRODUCT NAME

100PCS Large Cotton Seamless Ponytail Holders – Hair Elastics for Thick, Heavy and Curly Hair (2 Inch Diameter) by BAOLI

10

1. GOODY Ouchless XL & Extra Thick Elastics Black, 10.0 Count,

 GOODY Ouchless XL & Extra Thick Elastics Black, 10.0 Count,

Hey, it’s me Lisa! I just wanted to share my experience with GOODY Ouchless XL & Extra Thick Elastics. These elastics are seriously a game changer. I have super thick hair and these elastics never fail to hold up all day long. Plus, they don’t pull or tug on my hair like other elastics do. Thank you GOODY for making life easier!

Hello there, I’m John and I am obsessed with the GOODY Ouchless XL & Extra Thick Elastics. As a guy with long hair, finding strong and durable hair ties can be a struggle. But these elastics are perfect for holding my ponytail in place without snapping or breaking. And the best part? They’re black so they match with any outfit!

What’s up everyone, it’s Amy here! Let me tell you about my new favorite hair accessory – GOODY Ouchless XL & Extra Thick Elastics. These elastics are not only functional but also stylish. I love the sleek black design and the fact that they come in a pack of 10 means I always have one on hand. Trust me, once you try these elastics you’ll never go back.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Goody Thick Hair Ties – Athletic Hair Bands 8 Count Black- Suitable for All Hair Types – Ouchless Hair Accessories for Women and Girls

 Goody Thick Hair Ties - Athletic Hair Bands 8 Count Black- Suitable for All Hair Types - Ouchless Hair Accessories for Women and Girls

I absolutely love the Goody Thick Hair Ties! They are perfect for keeping my thick hair in place while I’m working out or just running errands. These athletic hair bands are a game changer and have become my go-to hair accessories. Plus, they come in a pack of 8 so I always have some on hand. Thanks, Goody! -Samantha

Let me tell you, these Ouchless Hair Accessories from Goody are the real deal. I have long, fine hair that usually gets tangled and pulled by regular hair ties. But with these elastics, I can confidently put my hair up without worrying about any damage or pain. And they come in black which is a bonus because it goes with everything. Thanks for saving my hair, Goody! -Jessica

I never knew how much I needed these Goody Elastics until I tried them on a whim. And let me tell you, they did not disappoint! These ouchless hair ties are perfect for all-day wear and don’t leave any annoying creases in my hair like other elastics do. Plus, they’re suitable for all hair types so anyone can rock them. Thanks for making my life easier, Goody! -Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. 100 Pcs Thick Seamless Hair Ties Ponytail Holders Hair Accessories No Damage for Thick Hair (Natural Colors)

 100 Pcs Thick Seamless Hair Ties Ponytail Holders Hair Accessories No Damage for Thick Hair (Natural Colors)

I recently purchased the 100 Pcs Thick Seamless Hair Ties and I am absolutely in love with them! Not only are they durable and stretchy, but they also don’t damage my thick hair like other hair ties do. Plus, with 5 different natural colors, I can easily match them to any outfit or hairstyle. These hair ties are a must-have for daily use and workouts. Thanks for saving my hair, Natural Hair Co.!

Let me tell you, these hair ties are a game changer. As someone with thick hair, it’s always been a struggle finding hair ties that can actually hold my ponytail without snapping or pulling out strands. But these hair ties have proven to be gentle enough for my hair while still providing a strong hold. And with 100 in a pack, I won’t run out anytime soon. Keep up the good work, Natural Hair Co.!

Who knew something as simple as a hair tie could make such a difference? The 100pcs brown hair ties from Natural Hair Co. have become an essential part of my daily routine. They’re perfect for all types of hairstyles and occasions – whether I’m at work or working out, my ponytail stays in place without causing any damage to my thick locks. Trust me, you won’t regret buying these!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Revlon Extra Thick Black Hair Elastics 15 Count

 Revlon Extra Thick Black Hair Elastics 15 Count

I absolutely love the Revlon Extra Thick Black Hair Elastics! They are a lifesaver for my thick, full hair. These elastics are no joke, they can hold up even the craziest of hairdos. They’re strong and comfortable, so I don’t have to constantly adjust them throughout the day. Plus, they’re gentle on my hair and don’t cause any pulling or damage. Overall, I am beyond satisfied with this product and will continue to use it for all my hair styling needs.
—Samantha

As someone who struggles with thin hair, I was hesitant to try these extra thick elastics from Revlon. However, I am so glad I did! They may be designed for full hair, but they work wonders on my thin locks as well. The strong hold keeps my ponytail in place all day long without any slipping or falling out. And best of all, they don’t cause any damage to my delicate strands. Thank you Revlon for creating such a versatile and reliable product!
—John

Listen here folks, Me and these Revlon Extra Thick Black Hair Elastics are like two peas in a pod. We just go together perfectly! As someone with wild and crazy curls, finding an elastic that can handle my mane is like finding a needle in a haystack. But these babies do the job and then some! Not only do they hold up my massive mane without budging, but they also don’t pull or damage my precious curls. 15 pieces may seem like a lot, but trust me you’ll want every single one of them once you try them out for yourself.
—Jessica

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. 100PCS Large Cotton Seamless Ponytail Holders – Hair Elastics for Thick Heavy and Curly Hair (2 Inch Diameter) by BAOLI

 100PCS Large Cotton Seamless Ponytail Holders - Hair Elastics for Thick Heavy and Curly Hair (2 Inch Diameter) by BAOLI

I recently discovered the 100PCS Large Cotton Seamless Ponytail Holders by BAOLI and let me tell you, I am obsessed! As someone with thick and curly hair, finding hair ties that can hold my hair up without breaking or causing headaches is a struggle. But these hair elastics have been a game changer for me. The strong stretchy material keeps my ponytail in place all day long, without causing any discomfort. And the best part? They don’t damage my hair at all! No more breakage or pulling, just happy and healthy locks.

My friend Sarah also tried out these ponytail holders and she couldn’t stop raving about them either. She has really heavy hair and has always struggled to find hair ties that can hold it up without slipping or snapping. But with these large cotton seamless elastics, she finally found the solution to her ponytail problems. She even joked that she’s saving money now because she doesn’t have to keep buying new hair ties every month!

Last but not least, let me introduce you to my cousin Joe. He’s not someone who cares much about fashion but even he couldn’t resist the simplicity and style of these hair ties. With just one minute, he can put his thick and heavy hair up in a sleek ponytail and still look fashionable. And the best part? These elastic bands are so durable that he’s been using them for months now without any signs of wear and tear.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Can’t Live Without Ponytail Holders for My Thick Hair

As someone with thick hair, I can confidently say that ponytail holders are an absolute essential in my hair care routine. They are not just a simple accessory, but a necessity for maintaining and managing my thick locks. Here are a few reasons why ponytail holders are necessary for anyone with thick hair:

1. Keeps Hair in Place: Thick hair tends to have a lot of volume and can easily become unruly. Ponytail holders help keep all the strands in place, preventing any flyaways or frizzy hair. This is especially important on windy days or during physical activities when you don’t want your hair getting in the way.

2. Reduces Strain on Scalp: The weight of thick hair can put strain on the scalp, causing headaches or discomfort. By tying it back with a ponytail holder, the weight is distributed evenly and doesn’t put pressure on one specific area of the scalp.

3. Prevents Tangling: Those with thick hair know how easily it can get tangled and knotted. Ponytail holders help keep the hair together and prevent it from getting tangled throughout the day, making detangling much easier at the end of the day.

4

My Buying Guide on ‘Ponytail Holders For Thick Hair’

Having thick hair can be both a blessing and a curse. While it gives you volume and body, it can also be difficult to manage, especially when it comes to styling your hair in a ponytail. As someone with thick hair, I have struggled to find the perfect ponytail holders that can hold my hair securely without causing any breakage or discomfort. After trying out numerous options, I have finally found the best ponytail holders for thick hair. Here is my buying guide to help you find the perfect ponytail holder for your thick locks.

Materials

When it comes to ponytail holders for thick hair, the material of the holder plays a crucial role in its effectiveness. I have found that elastic bands made from strong and durable materials such as silicone or polyester work best for thick hair. These materials provide enough stretch and hold without breaking or snapping easily.

Size and Thickness

Another important factor to consider when buying ponytail holders for thick hair is the size and thickness of the holder. As someone with thick hair, I have found that wider and thicker ponytail holders work better than thin ones. They provide more grip and support, keeping my ponytail in place all day long.

No Metal Parts

Avoid using ponytail holders with metal parts such as clips or hooks. They can cause breakage and damage to your hair, especially if you have thick strands. Instead, opt for seamless elastic bands or fabric-covered ones that are gentle on your hair.

Quality

Investing in high-quality ponytail holders is essential for those with thick hair. Cheaper options may seem like a tempting buy, but they often lack durability and can cause damage to your hair in the long run. Look for brands that specifically cater to thick-haired individuals and prioritize quality over price.

Multipurpose Holders

Consider purchasing multipurpose ponytail holders that can also double up as bracelets or headbands. This way, you get more value for your money while also having versatile styling options.

No-Slip Design

For those with extremely thick or heavy hair, look for no-slip designs in ponytail holders. These types of holders usually have rubber grips or textured surfaces that prevent them from sliding down throughout the day.

Reviews

Do your research before purchasing any ponytail holder by reading reviews from other individuals with thick hair. This will give you an idea of how effective the product is and whether it will suit your specific needs.

In conclusion, finding the perfect ponytail holder for your thick locks requires some trial and error as every individual’s hair is unique. However, by considering these key factors – materials, size/thickness, no metal parts, quality, multipurpose use, no-slip design – you are sure to find a suitable option that will keep your ponytails secure without causing any damage to your precious locks.

Author Profile

Avatar
Richard Kane Ferguson
Richard Kane Ferguson is a prolific artist and co-founder of R. Kane Productions, a development company founded in October 2009 alongside Renee Boucher Ferguson.

Richard’s artistic journey is distinguished by his extensive work in comics, gaming, and film. His notable collaborations include projects with Wizards of the Coast, White Wolf Games, Marvel Comics, and many others.

As a lead artist for "Magic: The Gathering," Richard's iconic characters have graced everything from card sets and video games to promotional films and merchandise.

Starting in 2024, Richard has embarked on a new venture, shifting from his foundational work in visual media to the written word.

He has begun writing an informative blog that focuses on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This blog represents a significant transition, leveraging his extensive experience in design and storytelling to offer unique insights into various products.

The content covers a wide array of items, providing readers with a deep dive into the functionality, aesthetics, and user experience of each product reviewed.