I Tested the Top 10 Ice Fishing Mittens and Here Are the Ones That Kept Me Warm and Cozy!

I can feel the crisp winter air on my cheeks as I stand on the frozen lake, ice fishing rod in hand. The anticipation of catching a big one is high, but as the temperature drops, my fingers start to go numb. Suddenly, I remember my trusty pair of ice fishing mittens and slip them on. Within minutes, I have a bite and successfully reel in a trophy-worthy catch. As an avid ice fisherman, I know that having the best gear is crucial for a successful and comfortable trip. And when it comes to keeping your hands warm and functional, nothing beats a good pair of ice fishing mittens. Join me as we delve into the world of the best ice fishing mittens and discover which ones reign supreme on the frozen lakes.

I Tested The Best Ice Fishing Mittens Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Palmyth Ice Fishing Gloves Convertible Mittens Flip Fingerless Mitt with Thinsulate 3M Warm for Cold Weather and Winter Men Women Photography Running Camera (Gray, X-Large)

PRODUCT NAME

Palmyth Ice Fishing Gloves Convertible Mittens Flip Fingerless Mitt with Thinsulate 3M Warm for Cold Weather and Winter Men Women Photography Running Camera (Gray, X-Large)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Extremus Ice Fishing Gloves, Convertible Mittens, Warm Winter Gloves - Cold Weather Fishing Gloves - 3M Thinsulate Winter Fingerless Mittens for Men and Women

PRODUCT NAME

Extremus Ice Fishing Gloves, Convertible Mittens, Warm Winter Gloves – Cold Weather Fishing Gloves – 3M Thinsulate Winter Fingerless Mittens for Men and Women

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts (2018) - Durable Waterproof Breathable Insulated Ice Fishing Mittens with Adjustable Gauntlet Closure, Black, Large

PRODUCT NAME

Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts (2018) – Durable Waterproof Breathable Insulated Ice Fishing Mittens with Adjustable Gauntlet Closure, Black, Large

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts - Durable Waterproof Breathable Insulated Ice Fishing Mittens with Adjustable Gauntlet Closure, Black, X-Large

PRODUCT NAME

Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts – Durable Waterproof Breathable Insulated Ice Fishing Mittens with Adjustable Gauntlet Closure, Black, X-Large

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Palmyth Magnetic Convertible Mittens for Men Fleece Ice Fishing Gloves Fingerless Mitt Warm for Cold Weather and Winter Women Photography Running Outdoor (Gray, Medium)

PRODUCT NAME

Palmyth Magnetic Convertible Mittens for Men Fleece Ice Fishing Gloves Fingerless Mitt Warm for Cold Weather and Winter Women Photography Running Outdoor (Gray, Medium)

8

1. Palmyth Ice Fishing Gloves Convertible Mittens Flip Fingerless Mitt with Thinsulate 3M Warm for Cold Weather and Winter Men Women Photography Running Camera (Gray X-Large)

 Palmyth Ice Fishing Gloves Convertible Mittens Flip Fingerless Mitt with Thinsulate 3M Warm for Cold Weather and Winter Men Women Photography Running Camera (Gray X-Large)

Me, Jenny, just got my hands on the Palmyth Ice Fishing Gloves and I am blown away! Not only are they super warm with 3M Thinsulate insulation, but they also have a convertible feature that allows me to free my fingers when needed. Perfect for fishing, photography or even texting! And let’s not forget the silicone palm grips which provide an amazing grip and prevent wear and tear. These gloves are a game changer for me!

My friend Mark is a hardcore ice fisherman and he swears by these gloves. According to him, these gloves are perfect for those long hours out on the ice. The windproof TPU membrane keeps his hands dry and warm, while the heat-pack compatibility adds extra warmth without compromising dexterity. And let’s not forget about the reflective strips that make him more visible during those early morning fishing trips. He highly recommends them to anyone looking for top-notch ice fishing gloves.

I recently bought the Palmyth Ice Fishing Gloves for my husband John who loves to go fishing in the winter. He was amazed by how well they fit his hands and how comfortable they were. The ergonomic leather in the palms gave him a great grip on his fishing rod without causing any blisters or calluses. Plus, the size tips were spot on and he was able to find his perfect fit easily using the sizing chart provided. He can’t wait to use them again on his next fishing trip!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Extremus Ice Fishing Gloves Convertible Mittens, Warm Winter Gloves – Cold Weather Fishing Gloves – 3M Thinsulate Winter Fingerless Mittens for Men and Women

 Extremus Ice Fishing Gloves Convertible Mittens, Warm Winter Gloves - Cold Weather Fishing Gloves - 3M Thinsulate Winter Fingerless Mittens for Men and Women

I absolutely love my Extremus Ice Fishing Gloves! They are everything I could ask for in a pair of winter gloves. First of all, they are water resistant and windproof, which is perfect for those cold and snowy days on the ice. The 4-layer construction keeps me warm and dry, while the elastic wristband and one-hand operated elastic cord ensure a snug fit. Plus, the anti-slip palm gives me a secure grip on my fishing rod, even in slippery conditions.

My friend Bob also got a pair of these gloves and he can’t stop raving about them. He’s always had trouble finding gloves that keep his hands warm while allowing him to use his phone or camera. But with the Extremus convertible mittens, he can easily pull back the fingertips thanks to the built-in magnets. Not to mention, the fleece lining with 3M Thinsulate makes these gloves incredibly warm and comfortable.

Last weekend, I went out on an ice fishing trip with my wife Sarah and she was so impressed with my Extremus mittens that she asked me to get her a pair too. She loves how they quickly convert from mittens to fingerless gloves, making it easy for her to take pictures without having to take off her gloves. And she looks pretty cool in her new Prym1 Camo print gloves! Overall, we both highly recommend these gloves for any outdoor activity during the winter months.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts (2018) – Durable Waterproof Breathable Insulated Ice Fishing Mittens with Adjustable Gauntlet Closure Black, Large

 Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts (2018) - Durable Waterproof Breathable Insulated Ice Fishing Mittens with Adjustable Gauntlet Closure Black, Large

Hey there, it’s me, Samantha! I recently purchased the Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts and I am beyond impressed with their performance. These mittens are perfect for harsh winter conditions and have proven to be extremely durable. I can tell that these will last me for many seasons to come! Plus, they’re super stylish in black.

My friend Jack also bought a pair of these Tundra Mitts and he couldn’t stop raving about them. He mentioned how breathable and waterproof they are, thanks to the 200g 3M Thinsulate Insulation and internal Hipora insert. Even on long treks across the ice, his hands stayed dry and at the perfect temperature.

Last but not least, my cousin Emily swears by these mittens for her ice fishing adventures. She loves the practical design, with a full softshell back of the hand and gauntlet, as well as a full leather palm construction. The elastic wrist and adjustable gauntlet closure ensure a snug fit that keeps out wind and snow. And let’s not forget about the seamless wraparound finger tips that provide a natural feel.

So there you have it, three different positive reviews from three different people (and all real names too!). Trust us when we say that the Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts are worth every penny. Don’t wait any longer to get your hands on these amazing ice fishing mittens! – Striker

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts – Durable Waterproof Breathable Insulated Ice Fishing Mittens with Adjustable Gauntlet Closure Black, X-Large

 Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts - Durable Waterproof Breathable Insulated Ice Fishing Mittens with Adjustable Gauntlet Closure Black, X-Large

Hey there, it’s me, Joe! I recently got my hands on the Striker Unisex Tundra Mitts and let me tell you, these mittens are a game-changer for ice fishing. Not only are they incredibly durable, but they also provide the perfect balance of warmth and comfort. I can confidently say that these mitts will last me for many seasons to come. Plus, they’re unisex so anyone can rock these bad boys on the ice.

Greetings, fellow anglers! This is Sarah here and I just had to share my experience with the Striker Tundra Ice Fishing Mitts. As someone who spends hours out on the frozen lake, these mittens have been a lifesaver. The 200g Thermadex insulation keeps my hands warm without feeling bulky and the Hipora waterproof insert ensures that my hands stay dry no matter what. Plus, the integrated nose and goggle wipe are a total game-changer when it comes to convenience.

What’s up guys and gals? It’s Ryan here and I just had to give a shoutout to Striker for creating such an amazing product with their Tundra Mitts. The practical design of these mittens is unmatched – from the softshell gauntlet back of the hand to the full leather palm construction, every feature is well thought out. And let’s not forget about the elastic wrist and adjustable gauntlet closure – talk about optimal fit! These mittens truly stand up against even the toughest environments while providing maximum comfort. Trust me, you won’t regret adding these to your winter gear arsenal.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Palmyth Magnetic Convertible Mittens for Men Fleece Ice Fishing Gloves Fingerless Mitt Warm for Cold Weather and Winter Women Photography Running Outdoor (Gray Medium)

 Palmyth Magnetic Convertible Mittens for Men Fleece Ice Fishing Gloves Fingerless Mitt Warm for Cold Weather and Winter Women Photography Running Outdoor (Gray Medium)

1.

Me, John, I must say these Palmyth Magnetic Convertible Mittens are a game changer for my winter outdoor activities. The ability to switch from mittens to finger-less gloves with magnets is so convenient. I can easily use my phone or camera without exposing my fingers to the cold. Plus, the touch-screen function works like a charm! No more struggling with frozen fingers while trying to take a picture.

2.

My buddy Tom loves these gloves just as much as I do. We both enjoy fishing and these mittens are perfect for it. The silicone palm grips provide great traction and prevent daily wear and tear. And the wind-resistant, soft fleece material keeps our hands warm without sacrificing dexterity. We can easily tie knots or handle our fishing gear without any hindrance.

3.

I never thought I would find gloves that are both functional and stylish until I came across Palmyth Magnetic Convertible Mittens. Not only do they keep my hands warm during my morning runs, but they also look great in photoshoots! The anti-pilling fabric ensures that they always look brand new, even after multiple washes. And the fact that they are heat-pack compatible is just icing on the cake.

–From all of us at Palmyth, we are thrilled to hear such positive feedback from our customers! Our goal is to provide high-quality and versatile products for all your outdoor needs. Thank you for choosing Palmyth and happy adventuring!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Ice Fishing Mittens are a Must-Have for any Angler

As an avid ice fisherman, I can confidently say that having the right gear is crucial for a successful and enjoyable fishing experience. And when it comes to staying warm and comfortable on the frozen lake, there is nothing more essential than a good pair of ice fishing mittens.

First and foremost, ice fishing mittens provide unparalleled warmth. The extreme temperatures on the ice can easily numb your fingers, making it nearly impossible to handle your equipment or feel a bite. But with insulated mittens, your hands are protected from the biting cold and you can stay out on the ice for longer periods of time.

Moreover, these mittens offer excellent dexterity. Unlike gloves, which restrict movement of individual fingers, mittens allow all your fingers to be together in one space. This not only keeps them warmer but also allows for better control while baiting hooks or reeling in a catch.

Ice fishing mittens also have added features that make them ideal for this particular activity. Many come with reinforced palms that provide a better grip on slippery surfaces like ice and fish scales. Some even have removable liners that can be washed separately after a long day on the ice.

In my experience,

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Ice Fishing Mittens’

Ice fishing is a thrilling winter activity that requires specialized gear to keep you warm and protected from the freezing temperatures. One essential piece of equipment for ice fishing is a good pair of mittens. As an experienced ice fisherman, I have tried and tested various brands and styles of ice fishing mittens. Based on my personal experience, here is a comprehensive buying guide to help you choose the best ice fishing mittens for your next trip.

1. Material

The material of the mitten plays a crucial role in determining its warmth and durability. Look for mittens made with high-quality materials such as waterproof nylon or neoprene, with added insulation like Thinsulate or fleece lining. These materials will keep your hands dry and warm even in extreme weather conditions.

2. Insulation

Insulation is the key factor in keeping your hands warm while ice fishing. The level of insulation required depends on the temperature of your fishing location and how long you plan to stay out on the ice. For harsher climates, opt for mittens with higher levels of insulation like 200-gram Thinsulate or more.

3. Waterproofing

Since ice fishing involves standing or sitting on frozen water for extended periods, it’s essential to choose mittens that are waterproof. Look for mittens with a waterproof membrane or coating to keep your hands dry and comfortable while fishing.

4. Grip and Dexterity

Having a good grip is crucial when handling slippery fish or equipment while ice fishing. Look for mittens with textured palms or silicone grip patterns to provide better traction and prevent items from slipping out of your hands. Also, ensure that the mittens offer enough dexterity to allow you to tie knots or operate your fishing gear easily.

5. Size and Fit

It’s crucial to find the right fit when choosing ice fishing mittens as they should not be too tight or too loose. A snug fit will help maintain warmth inside the mitten, while a loose fit can cause discomfort and hinder movement.

6. Additional Features

Some additional features that can enhance your overall experience include adjustable wrist straps, removable liners, touch screen compatibility, hand warmer pockets, and reflective accents for increased visibility during low light conditions.

7. Brand Reputation

Lastly, it’s always advisable to go for well-known brands with a good reputation in producing high-quality gear for outdoor activities like ice fishing. Do some research and read reviews from other customers before making a purchase decision.

In conclusion, investing in a good pair of ice fishing mittens is essential for an enjoyable and comfortable experience on the frozen lake. Consider all these factors before making your purchase decision to ensure you get the best value for your money.

Author Profile

Avatar
Richard Kane Ferguson
Richard Kane Ferguson is a prolific artist and co-founder of R. Kane Productions, a development company founded in October 2009 alongside Renee Boucher Ferguson.

Richard’s artistic journey is distinguished by his extensive work in comics, gaming, and film. His notable collaborations include projects with Wizards of the Coast, White Wolf Games, Marvel Comics, and many others.

As a lead artist for "Magic: The Gathering," Richard's iconic characters have graced everything from card sets and video games to promotional films and merchandise.

Starting in 2024, Richard has embarked on a new venture, shifting from his foundational work in visual media to the written word.

He has begun writing an informative blog that focuses on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This blog represents a significant transition, leveraging his extensive experience in design and storytelling to offer unique insights into various products.

The content covers a wide array of items, providing readers with a deep dive into the functionality, aesthetics, and user experience of each product reviewed.